Swift for Beans – about null, nil and Optional.orElse(“?!”)

As you may have gathered, I have found an interest in Swift. I have always found it easier to pick up new languages by comparing it to the one I know best, Java.

Please note, this series is intended for experienced Java Developers. I will not go into details of Java or its API. Where sensible I will provide relevant links.

Tony Hoare, inventor of null (aka nil), famously proclaimed it to be his “…billion dollar mistake”. This should not be interpreted as null/nil being evil per se, denoting the absence/not-existence of a value is essential for data processing, but rather the absence of sensible language features to handle null/nil values.

To fully appreciate this you have to jump a couple of sentences further: “… More recent programming languages like Spec# have introduced declarations for non-null references. This is the solution, which I rejected in 1965.”

Unlike Java, Optional is an integral part of Swift language. In Swift variables may not be assigned nil (null), either they have to be initialized with a value or declared as an ? optional.

Any attempt to assign a non-optional variable with a nil value results in a compilation error.

Java on the other hand leaves null handling completely open, the introduction of Optional in Java 8 has provided API level functionality, sadly it has several design flaws which mitigate its usefulness (see Java 8 Optional: What’s the Point? and Why Isn’t Optional Serializable? ).

Just like in Java optionals have to be unwrapped, this can either be done by force unwrapping the optional with !.

The preferred way of handling optionals is optional binding, if the value exists it is unwrapped and assigned to a temporary variable/constant.

Force unwrapping a nil optional will still cause a runtime error, and as such should be avoided.

In contrast Java’s null handling can seem rather archaic, with the one exception being Optional in combination with lambdas.

In plain vanilla Java code ternary operator are often employed, to assign default values in case of null, with Java 8 Optional you can also use .orElse(...).

Swift has an explicit nil coalescing operator ??, allowing for easy assignment of default values.

Swift allows optional chaining, enabling the chaining of multiple optional calls. The output will be an optional which may be nil.

Doing the same in Java requires a long chain of multiple null checks, or the use of null objects (see Null Object Pattern).

Sadly it is not advisable to use Optional in domain models since they are not Serializable, which makes serializing across system boundaries (e.g. RMI, JAX-RS, JAX-WS, etc…) difficult. It can also wreak havoc when employed in passivatable context in stateful applications (such as CDI).

IBM hosts a public Swift-Sandbox, that allows you to try out Swift. This posts Swift code is published in a sandbox here for you to try out.

The next post will cover Swifts handling of variables, constants and types.

Further Resources:
Swift – The Basics
Swift – Optional Chaining
Understanding Optionals in Swift
Optionals Brocken (Java)
Java 8 Optional: What’s the Point?
IBM Swift Sandbox


I would like to thank Björn Sonntag and Robert Meyer for reviewing my posts.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *